More Experimental Rules

I’ve previously profiled experimental rules being used in the Pioneer and Atlantic Leagues. However, there is a different experimental rule at each level of the affiliated minor leagues too, which started their season yesterday. Here they are:

AAA—The bases are 18 inches across instead of 15. The idea is to reduce injury and make circling the bases marginally faster. Seeing as it narrows the distance between bases by only three inches, I’m guessing the change in base running times will be negligible. However, a bigger bag my reduce collisions at least at first base.

AA—In the first half of the season, infielders must set up with their feet on the dirt—no short outfield positioning. In the second have, in addition to keeping their feet in the dirt, there half to be two infielders on either side of second—no overloading one side of the infield with the shift. Obviously these are intended to increase the numbers of base hits.

High-A— Pitchers have to disengage from the rubber before trying to pick off a runner; otherwise it’s a balk. This particularly affects the pick off move for a left handed pitcher trying to throw to first. The hope is to increase stolen base attempts.

Low-A—Also wanting to increase stolen bases will have a rule limiting the pitchers to two step offs or pick off throws per plate appearance. A third one would be a balk. This one seems a bit extreme to me.

Low-A west—The pitch clock will be shortened to 15 seconds with clocks placed in the outfield and between each dugout and the area behind home. Speeding up the game more and ensuring the ump and pitcher can’t miss seeing the clock.

Low-A south—Automated ball/strike calls. The umps wear an earpiece, hear the call and repeat it. This isn’t just to ensure accuracy/consistency of the calls; it will also enable the league to adjust the strike zone in the future too.

3 thoughts on “More Experimental Rules

  1. For the bigger base thing, this is dumb. All you need to do is put a double first base like they have in softball. You only need it at first. The rest of the bases should be left alone. Forget what my girlfriend says, adding 3 inches won’t make enough of a difference.

    I’m no fan of eliminating the shift through rules. If you want to get rid of it, teach people how to hit opposite field, or gasp bunt.

    Limiting pickoffs is also really dumb. I hate pitchers who throw over 4-5 times, but to put an artificial limit on it is just not baseball.

    I am 100% for robot umpires and for pitch clocks. Also let’s enforce the rules that batters can’t just step out whenever they want.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I don’t have a problem requiring pitchers to disengage from the rubber on a throw to a base. A lot of lefties’ moves to first look like balks to me anyway. However, I totally agree limiting the step off or throw over is just dumb. A good base stealer might as well just be awarded second on a single…in fact, there will be little incentive to try to stretch a single into a double for a player who knows he’s going to have an easy time swiping the base or advancing on a balk anyway.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. All good points, fellas. (Oh snap! I used the word “fellas”!)

    I apply the Costner Ratio to actual baseball games:
    Field of Dreams at 1 hour 47 minutes, lots of ballplaying, excellent movie.
    Bull Durham at 1:48 outstanding on field and off. I always give candlesticks.
    For Love of the Game at 2:17, a bit too much navel contemplating on the mound. Lots of great moments, but overall not as good a movie as our first two selections.

    The point being: we’re here to watch you throw the ball and you try to hit it. We ain’t interested in your two minute psych-yourself-up rituals.


Join in on the conversation!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s