Not Quite Perfect, Jim

Aug 2, 2010.  With two outs in the top of the 9th, Armando Galarraga of the Detroit Tigers is on the verge of a perfect game.  He induced the batter to ground the ball to 1B Miguel Cabrera, who tossed to Galarraga as he raced the ver to cover the bag.  Galarraga caught the ball and stepped on first half a stride ahead of the batter.  Easy call, out, game over, history for Galarraga.

Well, history for Galarraga, anyway.  One of the best umps in the game, Jim Joyce, did not hesitate in calling the batter, wrongly, safe.  No hitter gone, perfect game gone.  Galarraga quickly finished off the Cleveland Indians to preserve the win. Joyce found himself on the receiving end of a lot of profanity from Tigers fans and players, but not from Armando Galarraga.

By the time Joyce got back to the umps’ clubhouse, he’d seen a replay and knew he’d blown the call.  He graciously consented to an interview and admitted his mistake.  He apologized to Galarraga, who forgave him.  He apologized to baseball fandom, although I don’t think we were owed one—but I said he’s one of the best umps in baseball, and owning his mistakes is part of why.

Nowadays there’s the replay rule to prevent such things, but there wasn’t then.  Instead, if anything, the game is far more famous as the only perfect game in baseball history broken up by a bad call on what should have been the final out.

It was the peak of Galarraga’s career. Both he and Joyce still accept interviews about that day graciously.

4 thoughts on “Not Quite Perfect, Jim

  1. I still feel like the proper way for that to have been handled was for the ump’s union to have requested that the Commissioner correct the call and award the perfect game. I was not in favor — and would never be — of a Commissioner unilaterally changing calls or game results (which people then wanted Selig [ptoo, ptoo] to do). However, since Joyce acknowledged it, I think it would have been acceptable for the union to request the change and MLB agree to that. I don’t know if the rules allow that, but it would have been a nice solution.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Sad thing is that if Cabrera had stayed home and covered 1B, it was an easy play for the 2B. I think Joyce saw how far Cabrera went to his right and subconsciously thought it would be a difficult play and expected it wouldn’t be made. Add in the fact Galarraga made a bit of a snow cone catch and I think it’s understandable how Joyce missed the call.


  3. I had long admired Jim Joyce prior to that game, both for his professionalism and that distinctive strike call of his, but his sincere apology after that blunder raised my opinion of him significantly.

    Thought experiment: try to picture Bob Davidson, or Angel Hernandez or Cowboy Joe West apologizing after blowing a call like that.

    Yeah… me neither.


Join in on the conversation!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s