Pitch Clocks Inbound. Whether You Want Them Or Not!

It looks like MLB has really decided to dig their heels in on this one, as they are going to push forward with instituting a shot clock, err I mean pitch clock, whether anyone wants them or not.  (Emphasis Mine)

The reports indicate that a variety of pacing measures will go into effect in 2018, with a 20-second pitch clock perhaps the most visible and notable among them. Pitch clocks aren’t exactly new, as MLB has been experimenting with their use in the minor leagues by way of a 22-second pitch clock. If it does go into effect as the reports suggest, the rule would charge pitchers with a ball if they take more than 20 seconds between pitches (after one warning per game). Hitters, meanwhile, would be required to adhere to a 30-second timer between batters; after a warning (one per game), they would presumably be charged with a strike. Another set of rules would provide that a second mound visit to a given pitcher in the same inning must result in his removal from the game. In addition, future efforts would control the amount of time between innings and the number and length of pitching warm-ups, though that does not appear to be on the docket for the upcoming season.

As you may imagine, players are….less than thrilled about the proposed changes.  They are even less than thrilled that management has apparently decided to proceed without their approval.

Indeed, one player involved in the negotiations tells Rosenthal that he’s never seen players so unified against an issue.  Both Rosenthal and Crasnick suggest that the players feel pace of play can be enhanced by making improvements to the instant replay system and more closely monitoring down time between innings — neither of which would require a clock that would limit them on the field. The sentiment appears to be the exact opposite among MLB owners, as Rosenthal reports that they’re “strongly in favor” of the pace-of-play initiatives that the commissioner’s office is pursuing.

The proposed changes will shorten the typical game by approximately 10 mins each, however Yankee and Red Sox games may be shortened to just shy of 15 hours.

While personally, I’m not in favor of a shot clock, I do think both pitchers and batters take way to damn long between pitches.  I shouldn’t be able to get up for a bathroom break, make a ham sandwich, put a kid through college, and learn three foreign languages between the time it takes Pedro Baez to decide to throw the exact same pitch in the exact same location as the three before it.


The 20 second limit would make quite a change to the game.  According to Bleacher Report, the Average Time Between Pitches for 2017 was 23.8 seconds.  That’s nearly 4 seconds per pitch of us standing around watching nothing.

MLB’s Slowest Relievers

MLB’s Slowest Starters

Of course another problem in MLB, and it gets worse the closer we get to the off-season is the number of pitching changes that most managers will go through.  We can speed up pitchers delivery’s all we want, but if a pitcher can warm up, walk to the mound, warm up again, throw two pitches, then watch as the manager walks to the mound, only to replace him for the next batter (and the three after that), we won’t be seeing much of an improvement.  Why aren’t pitchers forced to face a minimum number of batters?

Secondly, with the addition of instant replay, it now takes a significant amount of time every time we challenge a play, for the manager to come out, the umpires to gather and talk, then slowly walk to the back of the field where an attendant gives them a headset as we all sit around and watch New York screw up yet another replay call.  Why hasn’t MLB learned from the NFL how to handle a replay yet?  Have a specific umpire on the damn premises watching every play, preparing for a potential replay, so that way when a challenge is issued, they can simply buzz down and say “yea, the guy actually was tagged out.”  It shouldn’t take any more than 30 seconds.

And finally, MLB really needs to enforce the rule that a batter cannot step out of the box unless they make contact with the ball, and must remain at the ready when in the box.  A swing and a miss should not be an exemption.  Get in there and fucking play ball.  Slow pitchers are not the only problem here.

And while we are at it, why don’t we shave a commercial or two off of each inning.  That’ll shave quite a bit of time off the pace-of-play!

So while everyone seems to agree that changes need to be made, there’s a lot of dispute as to how and where those changes need to be made.  It seems from a little bit of everywhere, and while I’m not particularly a fan of watching a clock tick down, (and most importantly I’m not excited for the moment where a game is won on a ball 4 call because the clock hit zero before the pitch, and we have to instant review that shit), if that’s what it takes to get players to speed the hell up, I’m game at this point.  Maybe I’m just getting too damn old, but I can’t deal with games that end past 10:30 anymore.  I have a life and I have a job and I just can’t do the 4 and a half hour affairs anymore.

12 thoughts on “Pitch Clocks Inbound. Whether You Want Them Or Not!

  1. In a perfect world, ballgames would take a maximum of two hours because all pitchers would work at the pace of Mark Buehrle, and no batter would dare call time at the last minute for fear of getting a chin-music serenade on the next pitch. Of course, in a perfect world there would be no 5-minute commercial breaks every half-inning and Joe West would have long-since retired and taken Angel Hernandez with him…

    …oh, and a beer at the ball park would cost two bucks…

    … and, of course, the Yankees would finish in the basement every year.


    1. I have some United Airlines airsick bags. Every time I get stuck on The Airline with the Pole Up its Ass™ because my flight on a decent airline has been cancelled, I collect the airsick bags and put them in my briefcase. Then I go home or to my hotel smiling at the first nauseous kid who has to use the seatback pocket instead. Then I like to imagine the United cabin crew and security personnel smacking the crap out of the little brat, partially because they’re such a bunch of jerks and partially because children are horrible.

      But here, you can have one of mine. Feeling better, hmmmmm?


  2. How will this work for tosses to first base? Will doing so reset the clock? If not will pitchers be a lot less able to keep runners close?

    I read somewhere that time between pitches has been gradually increasing apparently because extra recovery time for the pitcher between pitches results in a small but measurable increase in pitch velocity, which many of the pitchers are aware of. I can imagine a pitcher thinking ‘well now I got a guy on first but at least I don’t have to worry about the damn pitch clock’ and then making gratuitous soft throws to first with an infuriating obvious intent that per the rules nobody can do anything about.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The best thing to do if we want to solve this so-called problem is to limit the number of pitching changes per team per game. Now that would be interesting and still force some strategy. And we wouldn’t have 15 pitchers on a team dammit!


  4. This is so dumb. It’s not going to make a difference when they manage to shave 8 1/4 minutes off of a game. Gimme a break.


    1. I agree with you, philiac. The difference is going to be a gnat’s eyelash. And if they try to impose it, we are looking at possible work actions.

      BUT, if we could trade a pitch clock for doing away with that abomination of a free IBB rule I could think about it.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. I don’t think the end goal is to shave 10 mins off the total time of a game, rather to keep the game moving along at a quicker pace with less downtime between action. The game won’t be much faster, it’ll just feel that way. Which I agree is a problem. People are getting bored and turning the channel, or turning to their phones because there’s nothing happening on the field. I think the overall goal of these measures is a valid one, I just am not sure they are going about it the best way. I also think there’s a lot of other things they need to be doing to speed the game up, like maybe not allowing a manager to trot out every three pitches to throw a new pitcher in there. I for one don’t want to see another Nomar Garciparra taking 15 mins to readjust his gloves after every fucking pitch. Get in the box and play ball already!


Join in on the conversation!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s