James Shields Traded To White Sox

The Padres have agreed to trade James Shields to the White Sox in exchange for Erik Johnson and prospect Fernando Tatis Jr.  San Diego will also be picking up $31 of the $58 million still owed to Shields.

With Shields aboard, the expectation is that either Mat Latos or Miguel Gonzalez will lose his spot in the rotation. Regardless of whether the White Sox demote Latos or Gonzalez, their top four will likely consist of Sale, Quintana, Shields and Carlos Rodon as long as all four are healthy. Whether Shields will stay in that top four beyond 2016 is up in the air, though, as he could opt out of the final two years of his contract at season’s end. That would mean leaving $42MM on the table, however.

Shields, 34, isn’t the pitcher he was during his best years with the Rays and Royals, but he remains a competent innings eater who’s on pace to exceed the 200-inning plateau and surpass the 30-start barrier for the 11th straight season. That aside, Shields does come with red flags. After a dreadful final start with the Padres, Shields’ ERA (4.28) is at its highest since 2010. Further, his strikeout rate – which spiked to a personal-best 9.61 per nine innings last year – has regressed to 7.62 (closer to his 7.84 career average) and the control that he displayed in his earlier days has declined. Shields’ walk rate is at 3.61 per nine innings, which is in line with last year’s 3.6, and his velocity has dipped. To Shields’ credit, he has long been a capable ground-ball generator – at 48 percent this year, there’s no sign he’s slowing down in that area. That should help his cause as he shifts to the hitter-friendly confines of U.S. Cellular Field, but he does have the third-highest home run rate among qualified starters since last season (16.9 percent).

While Shields isn’t the pitcher he once was, he still represents a slight improvement over current options for Chicago and will provide some additional depth in case of injury, and came at little cost.  Neither of the two players San Diego received are expected to have significant impact, and at this point the deal seems to be more about washing their hands of a terrible deal and cutting whatever loses they could.

7 thoughts on “James Shields Traded To White Sox

  1. Does anyone know what the Padres are doing? Their owner publicly goes off on them for being bad and then this. I mean, Shields isn’t great but how does dumping him make them better? If I were Kemp, I’d get my house ready to sell.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ve been thinking on this for a few days now, and I still have no clue what San Diego was trying to accomplish here. They are not only eating most of the contract, but they are getting basically nothing in return. I can’t help but think they could have gotten more if they had waiting until the deadline and taken advantage of some desperate team looking for another arm.


      1. It’s like they decided if we’re going to suck, let’s not pay so much for it. So, we can suck cheaper, see? It’s nice though that the buck stops at the pitcher’s mound instead of the GM’s desk.


        1. Usually if you try to offload a high priced vet, you either dump the entire salary for crappy prospects, or pay the salary and get a good prospect. SD decided to get the worst of both worlds. And it’s a wonder why they are in the situation they are in.


        2. Which, okay if you’re going to rebuild, but it’s not clear that’s what they are thinking. And, again, if the owner is out there complaining how they stink…what’s he doing?


        3. Was it the owner or the GM that went off on how terrible they were? Either way, I’m kind of like…dude, isn’t it your fault? Take some fucking responsibility for putting together a shitty team, or hiring those that did.


        4. It was the owner, and he said the front office was doing fine — it was the players he blamed. I’m kinda glad for Kim Ng that she didn’t get hired there…but Preller is probably part of their problem.


Join in on the conversation!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s